Ottawa and Alberta have agreed to jointly guarantee the value of carbon credits for low-carbon projects. How they design those guarantees will decide whether Canada’s industrial carbon markets unlock tens of billions of dollars in new investment — or leave it on the table.
Strong carbon markets need bankable carbon credits
Big decarbonization projects like carbon capture take years to build and decades to pay off. Investors will only count on carbon credit revenue if they’re confident it will still be there in 2035 or 2040.
Carbon contracts for difference (CCfDs) give them that confidence. They are a government guarantee on the future value of carbon credits. Designed as insurance, they cost taxpayers little or nothing as long as governments keep their carbon pricing commitments.
Clean Prosperity has championed CCfDs since 2022. In May 2026, the federal and Alberta governments committed to a joint program. Now they need to get the details right.
The Ottawa–Alberta deal in numbers
75 Mt
of emissions reductions the federal and Alberta governments will jointly underwrite with CCfDs, for investments made from 2030 to 2040
$1.2B
combined maximum liability: up to $600 million each for Ottawa and Alberta
$130
per tonne: the effective carbon credit price both governments are targeting by 2040, up from about $30 today
$90B
in low-carbon investment that credit prices of $130–150 a tonne could unlock in Alberta, cutting emissions by 70 megatonnes a year
Sources: Canada–Alberta implementation agreement (May 15, 2026); Clean Prosperity, Top TIER (December 2025).
How carbon contracts for difference work
Industrial carbon pricing rewards companies that cut emissions. Facilities that beat their emissions performance standard earn carbon credits, which they can sell to facilities that don’t. For a carbon capture plant, a low-carbon hydrogen facility or a cement kiln, credit sales can make or break the business case.
The catch: credits are only worth what future governments and future markets say they’re worth. If a government weakens its carbon price, or the market is flooded with surplus credits, that revenue shrinks or disappears. Lenders and boards know this, so they heavily discount expected credit revenue — and projects that make sense on paper never get built.
Credit prices have fallen far behind the headline price
Alberta TIER credit prices vs. the fund price (headline price), dollars per tonne, 2020–2026
In 2020, credits traded almost at the headline price. By 2025, they were worth less than a quarter of it, even as the headline price kept rising. That gap is the risk carbon contracts for difference are meant to remove.
A carbon contract for difference fixes that. Government and a project developer agree on a guaranteed credit price — the strike price — for a set volume of credits over a set period. Then:
Government pays the difference
If credits trade below the strike price, the government tops up the project’s revenue. The project is protected if policy is weakened or the market is oversupplied.
Example: strike price $130, market price $90. Government pays the project $40 per tonne.
Gains can be shared
In a two-way contract, the project pays back part of the difference when credits trade above the strike price. Sharing the upside rewards projects that perform well and gives taxpayers some return. A one-way contract works like a price floor: the project keeps the full market price.
Example: strike price $130, market price $150. If the $20 gain is split 50/50, the project keeps $10 a tonne and pays the government $10.
Illustrative figures only. The Ottawa–Alberta agreement hasn’t said whether its contracts will be one-way or two-way, and strike prices haven’t been set.
Designed well, a CCfD works like insurance on the carbon price. If governments keep the commitments they’ve already made, credit prices stay on track and the contracts cost little or nothing. If a government backs away from its commitments, it pays. That’s the point: CCfDs put public money behind public policy, which makes the policy believable.
In other words, we will have skin in the game so that that market actually works.
Prime Minister Mark Carney, May 15, 2026
Contracts for difference are a proven tool. The U.K. has used them since the mid-2010s to finance new low-carbon power, and Germany now uses carbon contracts for difference to back industrial decarbonization. In Canada, the Canada Growth Fund signed the country’s first carbon credit guarantee — with Calgary’s Entropy Inc. — in December 2023.
Where things stand: the Ottawa–Alberta agreement
On November 27, 2025, the federal and Alberta governments signed a memorandum of understanding (MOU) that put industrial carbon pricing at the centre of a grand bargain on energy and climate. On May 15, 2026, they signed an implementation agreement that put numbers to those commitments.
What’s been agreed
- Joint carbon contracts for difference. Canada and Alberta will jointly fund CCfDs covering up to 75 million tonnes of emissions reductions, for investments made from 2030 to 2040.
- Each government has skin in the game. Each government’s liability is capped at $600 million. A government that fails to maintain its carbon pricing commitments, or repeals its carbon pricing law, takes on full liability for the contracts.
- A rising headline price. Alberta’s industrial carbon price, frozen at $95 a tonne since 2025, rises to $100 in 2027, $115 in 2030, $130 in 2035 and $140 in 2040.
- A floor under credit prices. Alberta will set a minimum credit price of $60 a tonne in 2030, rising to $110 in 2040, with a target effective credit price of $130 a tonne by 2040.
Credit prices are far below the 2040 target
Alberta carbon prices today and under the Ottawa–Alberta agreement, dollars per tonne
CCfDs alone can’t close this gap. The program’s combined liability of $1.2 billion works out to about $16 a tonne across the full 75 Mt. Getting credit prices to $130 depends mostly on market design: the price floor, benchmarks that tighten as emissions fall, and transparent, linked markets. CCfDs make those commitments believable. They don’t replace them.
What’s still to be decided
- Strike prices. The price the contracts guarantee, and how quickly it rises, will determine how many projects become bankable.
- Eligibility and allocation. Which projects qualify, and how contracts are awarded.
- Contract terms. Contract length, volumes per project and how payments are calculated and settled.
- The legal foundations. Alberta is expected to enact its price floor regulation by the end of 2026, and the federal government is updating the national carbon pricing benchmark.
The choices being made now will decide whether the program is a game-changer or a footnote. Companies planning projects that will earn credits in the 2030s need answers soon. For complex projects like carbon capture, 2030 is just around the corner.
What an ambitious, effective CCfD program looks like
Clean Prosperity has worked on the design of carbon contracts for difference since 2022, with industry, investors and governments. Here’s what the federal and Alberta governments should do to make their program succeed.
Finalize the design quickly
Projects that will earn credits in the 2030s are making investment decisions now. Ottawa and Alberta should finalize the program’s design as soon as possible, ideally alongside Alberta’s price floor regulation by the end of 2026.
Make the guarantee bankable
Strike prices should be high enough, and rise predictably enough, that lenders will count on credit revenue. A guarantee set too low won’t change investment decisions.
Make walking away costly
The contracts work because they put government money behind government commitments. The financial consequences of reneging must be large enough to convince investors that neither government will.
Standardize and open the door wide
Offer standard contracts with clear, up-front eligibility criteria, open to projects across sectors. Standard terms cut transaction costs and let companies plan with confidence, without years of one-off negotiations.
Bring transparency to credit prices
Contracts need a trusted reference price to settle against. Alberta should publish regular, official data on TIER credit transactions — which would also make the market more efficient for everyone.
Build a program that can grow
75 million tonnes is a strong start. If demand from viable projects exceeds the initial allocation, governments should be ready to expand the program, in Alberta and beyond.
Harmonize, then link
Use the federal benchmark update to bring provincial systems closer together, then open them to cross-border trading.
Beyond Alberta
The Ottawa–Alberta agreement is a template for the rest of the country. Joint federal-provincial CCfDs line up both governments’ incentives: each pays if it backs away from its own commitments, so neither has a reason to weaken the system and leave the other holding the bill.
British Columbia
The July 2026 Canada–B.C. Cooperative Prosperity Agreement upholds strong carbon markets and commits B.C. to explore a national carbon market. We’ve recommended that Ottawa and B.C. jointly offer CCfDs next.
Ontario
Our May 2026 report Credit Where Credit is Due recommends that Ontario and the federal government offer standardized, joint CCfDs to secure low-carbon investment in steel and other heavy industry.
Saskatchewan
Our September 2026 report A Nuclear Grand Bargain proposes a deal built around electricity: federal co-financing for Saskatchewan’s first nuclear reactor, alongside a restart of the province’s industrial carbon pricing system. With 2,600 MW of new nuclear power by 2050, the deal could cut 11 megatonnes a year while the province grows power generation by nearly 50%.
Linking and harmonizing carbon markets
CCfDs work best in deep, liquid markets with prices people trust. Today, Canada’s provincial carbon markets can’t trade with each other.
- More cuts at lower cost. Our August 2026 analysis, Rethinking linking, modelled linking the B.C., Alberta and Ontario markets. Prices converge, about seven million credits trade across provincial borders each year, and cumulative emissions cuts rise 84% while industry’s compliance costs fall.
- Momentum is building. In its July 2026 agreement with Ottawa, B.C. committed to explore a national carbon market. A First Ministers’ working group is exploring interprovincial carbon credit trading.
- Harmonize first. The federal benchmark update is, in our words, “a valuable opportunity to harmonize systems and create the conditions for linking carbon markets.”
- Linking strengthens CCfDs. A bigger market gives the contracts a more reliable reference price to settle against, which makes guarantees cheaper to offer.
How we got here
Clean Prosperity research and advocacy Government action
- Oct 2022Closing the Carbon-Pricing Certainty Gap is the first detailed Canadian proposal for carbon contracts for difference. Clean Prosperity
- Mar 2023Federal Budget 2023 commits to offering carbon contracts for difference through the Canada Growth Fund.
- Aug 2023Clean Prosperity joins industry associations and climate policy organizations in a joint letter urging the Finance Minister to create a broad-based CCfD program. Clean Prosperity
- Nov 2023The Fall Economic Statement allocates $7 billion of the Canada Growth Fund to carbon contracts for difference.
- Dec 2023The Canada Growth Fund signs Canada’s first carbon credit guarantee, with Entropy Inc.: $86.50 a tonne for up to nine million tonnes of credits over 15 years.
- Feb 2024Missing Megatonnes, with Navius Research, finds Canada could miss out on up to 33 megatonnes a year of emissions reductions by 2030 without broad-based CCfDs. Clean Prosperity
- Jun 2024The Canada Growth Fund publishes its carbon contracts strategy, including standardized contracts for smaller projects.
- Jul 2024Strengthening TIER warns that an oversupply of credits could undermine Alberta’s carbon market. Clean Prosperity
- Jul 2025Market Force proposes a federal-provincial grand bargain, including joint federal-provincial CCfDs. Clean Prosperity
- Nov 2025Ottawa and Alberta sign their MOU, committing to strengthen Alberta’s carbon market and back it with financial mechanisms.
- Dec 2025Top TIER shows credit prices of $130–150 a tonne could unlock $90 billion in investment in Alberta, and recommends joint CCfDs. Clean Prosperity
- May 2026The implementation agreement commits Ottawa and Alberta to joint CCfDs covering up to 75 million tonnes of emissions reductions.
- Jul 2026Following the Canada–B.C. agreement, Clean Prosperity recommends joint CCfDs for B.C. Clean Prosperity
- NextAlberta’s price floor regulation is expected by the end of 2026. Ottawa and Alberta must design the CCfD program and set strike prices.
Our role: from research to national policy
The joint CCfDs in the Ottawa–Alberta agreement reflect a policy Clean Prosperity has developed and championed since 2022:
- Original research on how CCfDs work, what they could unlock and how to design them, from Closing the Carbon-Pricing Certainty Gap (2022) to Top TIER (2025).
- Coalitions with industry, including joint letters with industry associations calling for broad-based CCfDs and stronger carbon markets.
- Direct work with governments in Ottawa, Edmonton, Victoria, Toronto and Regina.
- A public case made in The Globe and Mail, Calgary Herald, The Hill Times and The Hub, and in national coverage of the Ottawa–Alberta deal.
This program promises to be a game-changer for unlocking low-carbon economic growth — one that can be expanded across Canada.
Michael Bernstein, President and CEO, Clean Prosperity, on the Ottawa–Alberta agreement, May 15, 2026
For journalists
Covering carbon contracts for difference or carbon market reform? Here are the essentials. For interviews or background, contact us at media@cleanprosperity.ca.
Key facts
- A carbon contract for difference (CCfD) guarantees the future value of carbon credits. If credit prices fall below an agreed strike price, government pays the difference. In a two-way contract, the project also returns part of any gain when prices run above the strike price.
- On May 15, 2026, Canada and Alberta agreed to jointly fund CCfDs covering up to 75 million tonnes of emissions reductions, for investments made from 2030 to 2040, with liability capped at $600 million per government.
- Alberta’s headline industrial carbon price rises from $95 a tonne to $140 in 2040. A credit price floor starts at $60 in 2030 and rises to $110 in 2040. The target effective credit price is $130 by 2040.
- Alberta’s TIER system covers more than half of Canada’s industrial emissions. Its credits have recently traded at about $30 a tonne.
- Clean Prosperity modelling finds credit prices of $130–150 a tonne could unlock more than $90 billion in low-carbon investment in Alberta and cut emissions by more than 70 megatonnes a year.
- The Canada Growth Fund signed Canada’s first carbon credit guarantee, with Entropy Inc., in December 2023.
Frequently asked questions
Will carbon contracts for difference cost taxpayers money?
It depends on the design. If strike prices are set close to where credit prices are expected to trade, the contracts work as insurance. They pay out only if prices fall short, mainly because a government weakened its commitments or let the market become oversupplied. If strike prices are set well above expected market prices, the contracts work more like a subsidy and will cost money.
The program details haven’t been announced. Under the agreement, each government’s liability is capped at $600 million, and a government that breaks its own carbon pricing commitments takes on full liability for the contracts.
Is this the carbon tax?
No. CCfDs apply only to industrial carbon pricing — the systems that price emissions from large industrial facilities. The consumer carbon price on fuel ended in April 2025. Industrial carbon pricing is run by provinces, and governments across the political spectrum, including Alberta, have used it for years. Alberta introduced its system in 2007.
Why guarantee credit prices rather than the headline carbon price?
Because credit prices are what pay for projects. Companies that cut emissions earn credits and sell them. Credits can trade far below the headline price when the market is oversupplied: Alberta’s headline price is $95 a tonne, but credits have recently traded at about $30. A guarantee tied to credit prices protects the revenue projects actually depend on.
Who will issue the contracts, and who can get one?
The federal and Alberta governments will jointly fund the contracts. Details such as who administers the program, which projects are eligible and how contracts are awarded have not yet been announced. Separately, the Canada Growth Fund has signed individually negotiated carbon contracts with companies since 2023.
What kinds of projects could benefit?
Any project that earns carbon credits by cutting emissions below its regulated benchmark. In Alberta, Clean Prosperity’s modelling shows carbon capture, utilization and storage is by far the biggest opportunity, along with energy efficiency and fuel switching in oil and gas, chemicals, refining, pipelines and cement.
Have carbon contracts for difference been used elsewhere?
Yes. The U.K. has used contracts for difference since the mid-2010s to finance new low-carbon power, and Germany uses carbon contracts for difference to support industrial decarbonization. In Canada, the Canada Growth Fund has signed carbon contracts with firms including Entropy Inc. and Markham District Energy.
Glossary
Key terms
- Carbon contract for difference (CCfD): a contract that guarantees a project a set price (the strike price) for its carbon credits. Two-way contracts also return some of the gain to government when market prices run above the strike price.
- Strike price: the credit price a CCfD guarantees.
- Carbon credit: a tradable unit, usually one tonne of CO₂e, earned by a facility that emits less than its benchmark. Facilities that emit more than their benchmark can buy credits to comply.
- Headline price: the price per tonne a facility pays on emissions above its benchmark if it doesn’t use credits. It sets a ceiling on credit prices.
- Effective credit price: the price at which credits actually trade. This is what determines the incentive to invest.
- Price floor: a minimum price for credits, set in regulation.
- TIER: Alberta’s Technology Innovation and Emissions Reduction regulation, the province’s industrial carbon pricing system and Canada’s largest carbon market.
- Output-based pricing system (OBPS): the type of industrial carbon pricing used in most provinces, including TIER. Facilities pay only on emissions above a performance benchmark, which protects competitiveness while keeping the incentive to cut emissions.
- Federal benchmark: the minimum standards every provincial and territorial carbon pricing system must meet.
Media enquiries
Email media@cleanprosperity.ca with your outlet, topic and deadline, and we’ll connect you with the right spokesperson.
Selected coverage
Ottawa-Alberta deal is the best outcome climate advocates could have hoped for (Michael Bernstein, The Globe and Mail, May 21, 2026)
Alberta-Ottawa energy deal could unlock billions in low-carbon investment, report says (The Globe and Mail, December 4, 2025)
Further reading
Reports
- Credit Where Credit is Due (May 2026)
How carbon market reforms, including joint CCfDs, can protect Ontario steel and mobilize low-carbon investment. - Mobilizing domestic institutional investment for Canadian decarbonization (June 2026)
Canadian institutional investors say CCfDs can help mitigate the policy uncertainty holding back investment. - A Canadian Advantage (March 2026)
With the Transition Accelerator: guaranteeing carbon credit revenues can help Canada win investment the U.S. is leaving behind. - Top TIER (December 2025)
Credit prices of $130–150 a tonne could unlock more than $90 billion in low-carbon investment in Alberta. - Market Force (July 2025)
Our vision for a federal-provincial grand bargain built on stronger carbon markets and joint CCfDs. - Strengthening TIER for Alberta’s Low-Carbon Growth (July 2024)
How Alberta can prevent an oversupply of credits from undermining investment. - Missing Megatonnes (February 2024)
With Navius Research: up to 33 megatonnes a year of emissions reductions by 2030 depend on broad-based CCfDs. - The Low-Carbon Playbook (October 2023)
With the Transition Accelerator: how carbon contracts can close investment incentive gaps between Alberta and the U.S. - Closing the Carbon-Pricing Certainty Gap (October 2022)
The first detailed proposal for carbon contracts for difference in Canada.
Statements
- Federal-B.C. agreement upholds carbon markets and low-carbon economic growth (July 2026)
We recommend that Ottawa and B.C. jointly offer CCfDs. - Ottawa-Alberta carbon pricing deal strikes difficult balance between climate, economy, and unity (May 2026)
Our response to the implementation agreement and its joint CCfDs. - Grand bargain could herald the policy reset Canada needs (November 2025)
Our response to the Ottawa–Alberta MOU. - Budget 2025 is right to focus on industrial carbon pricing (November 2025)
Our response to the federal budget. - New standardized carbon contracts a move forward for low-carbon projects (June 2024)
On the Canada Growth Fund’s carbon contracts strategy. - Budget 2024 makes important progress on carbon contracts for difference (April 2024)
On the expanded federal program. - First carbon contract for difference in Canada a strong step forward (December 2023)
On the Canada Growth Fund’s deal with Entropy Inc. - Fall Economic Statement’s carbon contracts for difference are an important boost (November 2023)
On the $7 billion allocation to the Canada Growth Fund.
Commentary and op-eds
- Rethinking linking: How to make interprovincial carbon credit trading stick (August 2026)
Brendan Frank on linking provincial carbon markets. - What does the Alberta-Ottawa deal mean for the federal carbon pricing benchmark? (June 2026)
Emily Rowan on what comes next for carbon pricing across Canada. - Ottawa-Alberta deal is the best outcome climate advocates could have hoped for (May 2026)
Michael Bernstein in The Globe and Mail on how joint CCfDs can make the deal stick. - Alberta-Ottawa MOU is a climate breakthrough (December 2025)
Michael Bernstein in The Globe and Mail. - Carbon contracts for difference face transparency and eligibility barriers (May 2024)
Etienne Rainville on credit price transparency and access to contracts. - Want to maximize Canada’s future energy economy? Embracing contracts for difference will be key (April 2023)
Why CCfDs are a market-based tool that should appeal to conservatives, in The Hub. - CCfD design series (August 2023)
Three posts on credit price uncertainty, keeping costs down and avoiding perverse incentives for provinces.
Joint letters and events
- Canadian industry proposes five fixes to industrial carbon pricing (October 2024)
Open letter from industry to provincial environment ministers. - Joint letter to the Finance Minister on carbon contracts for difference (August 2023)
Industry associations and climate policy organizations call for a broad-based program. - Canada must act now to remain competitive (March 2023)
Statement signed by 24 organizations calling for carbon contracts, among other measures. - High stakes for low carbon (March 2024)
Event with former Alberta Energy and Environment Minister Sonya Savage, KC. - Carbon contracts: What makes a difference? (October 2023)
Webinar on the state of the policy conversation.
Want to talk about carbon contracts for difference?
Our experts work with governments, industry and investors across Canada.
Get in touch