Canadian industry proposes five fixes to industrial carbon pricing

Industry sends open letter to provincial ministers of the environment

Industrial carbon markets are the most flexible and cost-effective way to incentivize industry to reduce emissions, and industrial carbon pricing is the “backbone of decarbonization across this country,” says an open letter from industry to Canada’s provincial environment ministers, sent today. 

Clean Prosperity signed the letter alongside 12 leading industry associations and firms from across Canada.

“We write to raise concerns about how provincial carbon markets work together, or rather how they do not,” the letter says. “The disconnect across nine different markets makes it harder to invest in major projects in Canada. It is holding back capital, economic growth, jobs, and decarbonization. We need to act now to fix this.”

Signatories to the letter include Alberta’s Industrial Heartland Association, Canadian Manufacturers & Exporters, the Canadian Renewable Energy Association, the Canadian Steel Producers Association, Carbon Removal Canada, the Cement Association of Canada, the Chemistry Industry Association of Canada, Clean Prosperity, Enhance Energy, Heidelberg Materials, Kiwetinohk Energy, Itoa Energy, and Lafarge

“We write to raise concerns about how provincial carbon markets work together, or rather how they do not,” the letter says.

The group proposes five fixes to help Canada’s industrial carbon markets achieve their full potential: 

  1. Remove interprovincial trade barriers. Carbon credits generated in one province should be recognized in another, and industry should be free to buy and sell carbon credits across provincial borders.
  2. Create and align high-integrity offset protocols. High-integrity offsets mean emissions reductions or removals that are “permanent, additional, and verifiable.” We need to start now to align those protocols to boost decarbonization. 
  3. Make credit markets transparent. Better transparency would “encourage greater participation, inspire investor confidence, and facilitate investment.”
  4. Enhance revenue recycling. Provinces should reinvest 100% of industrial carbon pricing revenues back into industry to accelerate further decarbonization. 
  5. Engage on measures at the border to support vulnerable sectors. Border measures can help to prevent carbon leakage to jurisdictions with less advanced climate policies. Provinces should push the federal government to accelerate the conversation about climate policy and the global competitiveness of Canadian industry.”

Canada is now less than two years away from the scheduled 2026 review of industrial carbon pricing systems. The time to start work on this is now. “To be successful, we need provincial leaders working together towards a common vision for decarbonization in this country,” the letter says. “Our economy and environment depend on it.” 

Suggested Reading

Ottawa-Alberta deal is progress but needs more climate ambition

Michael Bernstein, President and CEO of Clean Prosperity, made the following statement: “Yesterday’s energy investment agreement between Ottawa and Alberta represents continued progress in realizing the federal-Alberta grand bargain on climate and energy policy.  “The agreement has the potential to help grow Canada’s economy, diversify our trade, and reduce emissions, all while contributing to national

Federal-B.C. agreement upholds carbon markets and low-carbon economic growth

Clean Prosperity President and CEO Michael Bernstein made the following statement: “The Canada-British Columbia Cooperative Prosperity Agreement balances multiple critical objectives: economic growth, national unity, and emissions reduction. The future of Canada and B.C. depends on us succeeding at all of them. “The agreement explicitly upholds the power of strong carbon markets to attract low-carbon

New federal nuclear energy strategy an important step in supporting provincial reactor buildout

Brendan Frank, Clean Prosperity’s Vice President of Policy, made the following statement: “The federal government’s nuclear energy strategy is an important step forward in strengthening Canada’s nuclear power sector and supporting provinces in expanding nuclear power generation.  “It complements a broader strategy of electrification supported by the federal government and led by provinces. Ottawa is