New Emissions Data Is Not About the Carbon Tax

Clean Prosperity Executive Director Michael Bernstein made the following statement.

”A new Environment and Climate Change Canada report on Canada’s 2019 greenhouse gas emissions presents a mixed picture, as emissions rose slightly while emissions intensity continued to decline,” Clean Prosperity Executive Director Michael Bernstein said today. 

“This ECCC report can’t tell us much about the impact of the federal government’s carbon tax. The consumer-facing component of the tax was first implemented in April 2019. It was only in place for eight months of the year, and at a very low level—$20 per tonne.”

“The real power of the carbon tax comes from its ability to shift people’s behaviour over time, especially as the price of carbon continues to rise. The tax gives people a growing incentive to reduce their emissions.”

“Evidence shows that carbon taxes work. Since 2008, British Columbia has dramatically reduced its emissions intensity even as its economy has continued to grow at one of the fastest rates in the country. Emissions would have been 5-15% higher without the carbon tax.”

Our analysis, working with Navius Research, shows that carbon pricing alone can help Canada get most of the way to our 2030 emissions-reduction targets, and halfway to net-zero by 2050.” 

“That doesn’t mean we can be complacent. Emissions need to start falling in absolute terms and the federal government will need to take corrective action if this does not occur. It’s also incumbent on all federal and provincial political leaders to show how they would design a carbon pricing policy that could deliver steadily declining  emissions reductions.”

Suggested Reading

Synethic Crude Oil leaves Syncrude's Mildred Lake site via pipeline.

Pipeline benefits outweigh carbon costs in federal-Alberta climate deal

The financial benefits of new pipeline capacity will far outweigh the carbon costs outlined in last year’s federal-Alberta memorandum of understanding, according to new modelling from Clean Prosperity.  In their agreement the two governments committed to add at least one million barrels per day in new bitumen pipeline capacity and increase the minimum effective carbon

How Canada can outcompete the U.S. for low-carbon investment

In this era of trade wars and geopolitical rupture, Canada has a unique opportunity to build its industrial base by attracting low-carbon investment away from the United States. That’s the message of “A Canadian Advantage,” a new report released today by Clean Prosperity and the Transition Accelerator.  The report compares the incentives in Canada and

Canada’s nuclear expansion faces supply-chain and workforce risks

Canada’s plans to build new nuclear reactors could face major cost overruns and stalled projects if supply-chain and workforce bottlenecks are not addressed, warns a new report released today by Clean Prosperity. Canada has the opportunity to scale nuclear power as part of a broader effort to electrify its economy. There is room to more