New cap-and-trade system for oil and gas is not the right direction

Optimizing Canada's existing industrial carbon pricing systems would be a better approach

Photo by Chris Liverani on Unsplash

Clean Prosperity Western Director Adam Sweet made the following statement about the federal government’s new emissions cap for the Canadian oil and gas sector, announced today:

“The federal government’s decision to implement a cap-and-trade system solely for Canada’s oil and gas industry is the wrong policy. This approach creates uncertainty and regulatory complexity that risks slowing down critical emissions reductions. In our view, a better choice would be to optimize Canada’s existing industrial carbon pricing systems to achieve greater reductions.

“Industrial carbon pricing can do even more to reduce emissions right across the economy — including in the oil and gas sector — if the federal and provincial governments work together to tighten the stringency of emissions benchmarks. 

“The federal government should focus on supporting carbon pricing systems that are already working to reduce emissions, and accelerate the delivery of investment supports they have already committed to — such as carbon contracts for difference.”

Clean Prosperity Western Director Adam Sweet

“Instead of pursuing a new policy that creates uncertainty for firms, invites legal challenges, and risks disrupting the functioning of Canada’s industrial carbon pricing systems, the federal government should focus on supporting carbon pricing systems that are already working to reduce emissions, and accelerate the delivery of investment supports they have already committed to — such as carbon contracts for difference.

Carbon contracts for difference, which the federal government recently committed to deploying soon, put a guarantee on the price of carbon credits that trade within provincial industrial carbon pricing systems. Price guarantees can incentivize big investments in low-carbon projects, especially if they’re broadly available to emitters right across the economy. Firms are now looking forward to clarification from the government about how the contracts for difference program will work. 

“Alberta, Canada’s top producer of oil and gas, already has Canada’s largest and longest-running industrial carbon pricing system. With tighter benchmark stringency and guarantees on carbon-credit prices through contracts for difference, Alberta can accelerate emissions reductions from industry while growing a prosperous low-carbon economy. The new cap-and-trade system risks undermining the effectiveness of industrial carbon pricing in Alberta.

“With the federal government now committed to a cap-and-trade system for the oil and gas sector, it will be essential that the government make sure that the rules of the new system are clear to industry, including any interactions between the cap-and-trade system and existing climate policies, especially industrial carbon pricing.”

Contact: media@cleanprosperity.ca

Suggested Reading

Ottawa-Alberta deal is progress but needs more climate ambition

Michael Bernstein, President and CEO of Clean Prosperity, made the following statement: “Yesterday’s energy investment agreement between Ottawa and Alberta represents continued progress in realizing the federal-Alberta grand bargain on climate and energy policy.  “The agreement has the potential to help grow Canada’s economy, diversify our trade, and reduce emissions, all while contributing to national

Federal-B.C. agreement upholds carbon markets and low-carbon economic growth

Clean Prosperity President and CEO Michael Bernstein made the following statement: “The Canada-British Columbia Cooperative Prosperity Agreement balances multiple critical objectives: economic growth, national unity, and emissions reduction. The future of Canada and B.C. depends on us succeeding at all of them. “The agreement explicitly upholds the power of strong carbon markets to attract low-carbon

New federal nuclear energy strategy an important step in supporting provincial reactor buildout

Brendan Frank, Clean Prosperity’s Vice President of Policy, made the following statement: “The federal government’s nuclear energy strategy is an important step forward in strengthening Canada’s nuclear power sector and supporting provinces in expanding nuclear power generation.  “It complements a broader strategy of electrification supported by the federal government and led by provinces. Ottawa is